Property Appraisal vs Valuation: What Is the Difference?

An agent’s appraisal and a valuer’s valuation both put a number on your property, but they are made for different reasons. Here is when you need each one.

By the Find Best Agents team13 November 20266 min read
The short answer

An appraisal is a real estate agent’s estimate of what your property is likely to sell for, usually free, and based on recent comparable sales and market conditions. A valuation is a formal assessment of market value by a qualified valuer, usually paid for, and used by banks, courts, accountants and others who need a formal figure.

What an appraisal is

An appraisal is an agent’s opinion of the price your property is likely to achieve in the current market. The agent inspects the property and compares it with recent sales of similar properties nearby, adjusting for differences such as size, condition and position. Appraisals are usually free, because agents provide them when they hope to sell or manage your property.

Agents are not allowed to mislead you about price. Several states have specific underquoting laws, and in Victoria, for example, agents must base their estimate on comparable sales and provide price information to buyers. A good appraisal shows you the sales behind the figure.

What a valuation is

A valuation is a formal report on a property’s market value by a qualified valuer who has no stake in the sale. Valuers are typically members of professional bodies, and some states, such as Queensland, require them to be registered. A valuation follows set methods, is written up in a report, and costs money: often several hundred dollars for a standard home, more for complex or commercial property.

Appraisal vs valuation at a glance

AppraisalValuation
Who provides itA real estate agentA qualified valuer
PurposeEstimate the likely selling price or rentA formal opinion of market value for a specific use
CostUsually freeUsually paid
FormatOften a price range with comparable salesA written report with a single figure
Accepted by banks and courtsGenerally noYes, when prepared for that purpose

Which one do you need?

  • Thinking about selling, or choosing an agent? An appraisal. Get one from each agent you interview, and compare the evidence behind each figure. See how to interview real estate agents.
  • Setting the rent for an investment property? A rental appraisal from a property manager.
  • Refinancing or buying with a loan? The lender will usually arrange its own valuation.
  • Divorce or separation, deceased estates, tax or legal matters? A formal valuation, because you may need a figure others will accept.

Why the two figures can differ

It is common for an agent’s appraisal and a bank valuation to be different. Valuers, especially for lenders, tend to be conservative and rely strictly on past sales, while agents are estimating what a buyer might pay in a competitive campaign. Neither number is a guarantee of what your property will sell for. The market decides that.

Be careful with very high appraisals

An appraisal well above every other agent’s, with little evidence behind it, can be a way to win your listing. It can lead to a long campaign and price reductions later. Ask every agent which recent sales support their figure. Our guide to signs you chose the wrong agent covers this and other warning signs.

Compare appraisals the easy way

Find Best Agents interviews agents in your area for you and looks closely at how each one supports their price estimate, so your shortlist is built on evidence, not the highest number.

Want us to find and interview agents for you?Tell us about your property and we will shortlist the agents worth meeting.
Find My Agent →

Common questions

Is a free online property estimate the same as an appraisal?

No. Online estimates are calculated automatically from data and do not see inside your property. They are a rough starting point. An agent’s appraisal or a valuer’s report takes the property itself into account.

How much does a property valuation cost?

For a standard home it is often several hundred dollars, and more for larger, unusual or commercial properties. Ask the valuer for a quote before you book.

Get started

Ready to find the right agent?

Tell us about your property and what matters to you. We'll take it from there.