Interview three agents who have recently sold properties like yours nearby. Give each one the same information, ask each the same questions, ask for their price estimate, marketing plan and fees in writing, then compare the evidence side by side before you decide.
Why interview more than one agent
Each agent will tell you how they would sell your property, what they think it is worth and what they charge. On its own, one pitch is hard to judge. Put three side by side and the differences become clear: who has the stronger evidence for their price, whose marketing plan is more thorough, and who listens to what you actually need.
How many agents to interview
Three is usually enough. It gives you a real comparison without turning the process into weeks of appointments. If the first three give you very different price estimates, a fourth opinion can help you work out which figure is realistic.
Step 1: Choose who to interview
Pick agents with a track record that matches your property, not simply the most familiar names in the area. Look for recent sales in your suburb, sales of similar properties, and how close their final prices came to the first advertised price. Our guide to choosing a real estate agent explains what to look for.
Step 2: Prepare before the first meeting
- Write down your goals. Your ideal timing, the price you need, and anything that matters to you, such as a quiet campaign or a quick settlement.
- Gather the facts about your property. Land size, recent renovations, council approvals, rates and any known issues.
- Give every agent the same information. If one agent hears about your new kitchen and another does not, their estimates are not comparable.
- Prepare your questions. Use our list of questions to ask a real estate agent and ask them in the same order each time. Our free, printable agent interview checklist puts them on one page with a score for each agent.
Step 3: Run each meeting the same way
Most agents will want to walk through the property, then sit down and talk you through their plan. Let them, but make sure you leave with answers to the same core questions:
- What do you think the property will sell for, and which recent sales support that figure?
- Which sale method do you recommend, and why?
- What does your marketing plan include, and what will it cost?
- Who will run the inspections and the negotiation: you, or someone else in your team?
- What is your commission, and what exactly does it include?
- How long is the agency agreement, and how can it be ended?
Take notes during each meeting. After the third one, the first can be hard to remember accurately.
Step 4: Ask for everything in writing
Ask each agent to send their price estimate with the comparable sales behind it, their marketing plan and costs, their commission and a copy of the agency agreement. Written proposals are easier to compare and leave less room for misunderstanding later.
Step 5: Compare like with like
A simple table helps (the second page of our agent interview checklist is one, ready to print). List each agent across the top, and down the side: price estimate and evidence, sale method, marketing plan and cost, commission, agreement length, who handles your sale, and how well they listened. Then look at the full picture, not one line.
- Do not choose on price estimate alone. The highest estimate is not always the most accurate. Ask which estimate the evidence supports.
- Do not choose on commission alone. A lower rate can cost you more if the agent negotiates a weaker price. See real estate agent commission in Australia for a worked example.
- Trust what you observed. Punctuality, preparation and how quickly they replied to your questions are a preview of how they will run your campaign.
Step 6: Make your decision
Once you have chosen, tell the other agents politely that you have gone with someone else. Before you sign, read the agency agreement carefully, check that the commission and marketing costs match what you were told, and ask about anything you are unsure of. You are under no obligation to sign on the day.
If you would rather not do it yourself
Finding, booking and interviewing agents takes time. Find Best Agents does this work for you: we research the agents in your area, interview them on your behalf using the same questions for each, and present two or three who suit your property, with our notes. You meet them and make the final decision.
Common questions
Is it rude to interview several real estate agents?
No. Agents expect it, and most sellers meet more than one before they decide. Being clear that you are comparing a few agents usually leads to sharper proposals.
Do I have to pay for an agent to appraise my property?
Usually not. Most agents provide a selling appraisal free of charge when they are hoping to win your listing. A formal valuation from a valuer is different and does cost money.





